How Much Should I Fix Up My Rental Home for the Next Tenant?
The perfect scenario:
You are lounging on a sunny, deserted beach with your loving wife by your side. You have a cold drink in your hand as you marvel at the solitude and beauty of your surroundings. The only sounds you hear are the waves gently crashing in front of you and the occasional fluttering of a seagull’s wings. The sun subtly warms your skin before a timely breeze arrives to refresh you. You grasp your wife’s hand as she lovingly reciprocates. And you just filled your last rental property with a tenant. Life is perfect.
But, wait… is that your cell phone ringing in your beach bag? Who could be calling you? As you reach for the phone, your wife aggressively removes her hand from yours. “You better not answer that! We haven’t been away together since Eli was born and I’m not going to have our vacation ruined by work calls!” As your eyes refocus to the numbers on the phone, you realize it is the new tenant. “I’ve got to get this,” you mutter as your wife disgustedly begins to turn her beach chair away from you. You feign an enthusiastic greeting of “Hey Herb, what’s up? How’s the place?” as your eyes plead forgiveness to your now emotionally-estranged wife.
Herb begins his 10-minute rant, “This place is a dump! The whole house is filthy! The cabinets and appliances are especially gross and the entire trim needs to be repainted. The landscaping has been completely neglected and the yard is mostly weeds. My wife and I have spent our first 48 hours here on our hands and knees scrubbing and aren’t even close to being done! The air conditioning doesn’t even blow cold air. How could anyone live in this place??”
“Multiple tenants have managed to survive the experience in past 12 years I’ve rented it out,” you want to retort and then think better of it. You turn your head to see your wife disgustedly heading back towards the resort while pounding feverishly on her iPhone, undoubtedly spewing Facebook hate (Subject: You).
Herb is irate and you hear his wife trying to get into the action in the background. Once Herb says his piece, you tell him you’re very sorry, you’ll have someone over to look at the air conditioning, and will send the cleaners back (“No need! If they think the condition they left it in was clean, I don’t care to entertain their second act!”).
So this is bad. You thought you had the rental home in good shape and the tenants are ripping it apart. You look up at the resort and see your wife talking to the pool boy as she uncharacteristically is downing cocktails at 9 AM. This was supposed to be a relaxing, loving vacation and things are going very wrong.
What could have been done to avoid this tenant situation? Honestly, nothing. No matter how clean a house is left, some tenants will say it is filthy. Cleanliness is subjective.
There is a relatively predictable spectrum of responses from tenants after they move-in:
- 10% will be happy with whatever condition the home is in when they move-in
- 10% will be unhappy with whatever condition the home is in when they move-in
- 80% will be happy if the home is reasonably clean and touched-up when they move-in
So if things are reasonably clean, all major systems are working, and the house has been touched up, 90% of tenants will be happy. And everyone likes happy tenants.
And what about the unhappy 10%? It’s not a desirable situation, but there is a silver lining. You will take heat on the front end from them; that is for sure. And you won’t like it. But there are 2 positive takeaways:
- There was nothing you could have done to avoid their unhappiness. If you fixed your home up to such a pristine condition, it would crush the ROI on your investment property. And if you are going to pay to fix it up that much, do it only once and sell it for top dollar. Don’t do it every year. The objective (I’m told) is to make money on investments.
- When the initially unhappy tenants vacate, they will probably leave your home in move-in condition for the next tenant! This allows you to take the pain now to experience joy later.
So, to sum it up:
1. Fix-up your home in a reasonable manner between tenants. This means all systems working, touch-up paint (don’t repaint the house), steam cleaned carpet (don’t replace the flooring), and professional cleaning.
2. Hire a property manager so you don’t have to answer the phone on vacation.
3. Go get your wife!
Brett Furniss is the President & Owner of BDF Realty (Charlotte Residential Property Management), the trusted real estate advisor for Charlotte landlords & Home of $100 Flat Fee Property Management. BDF Realty utilizes their innovative Pod System for exceptional customer service in residential property management, home repairs, and home sales (including Rent-To-Sell) for single-family homes, condos, and town homes in the Charlotte-Metro Area. Contact Us Today!
Learn MoreThe #1 Question Tenants Ask When Vacating: Give Them the #1 Answer
“When will I get my (full) security deposit back?”
This is the #1 Question property managers get asked when tenants vacate. And this is the #1 opportunity to get the house back in the condition you want. Make sure you take it!
Note: This is not a full-proof plan! Some tenants have a completely different view of “clean” after they move out. As in, “Though the carpets are stained now and the walls are marked up, it is in better condition then when we moved in.” I get it: people can be temporarily delusional to further their own interests. As in, “I didn’t know that the McDonald’s coffee would be hot because it didn’t have a warning on the cup, I swear.”
When I hear the #1 Question through property manager ears, it really sounds like they are asking, “What do I need to do to get my full security deposit back as quickly as possible?” Fortunately, that is precisely the question we want them to be asking!
Getting a house back from the tenant in great condition is a win-win-win for all involved:
1. Tenants: They get all of their security deposit back- yeah! I root for all of our tenants to do this.
2. Owners: They get a property that can immediately go back to market and requires minimal cleaning/fix-up costs.
3. Property managers: They don’t have to take a lot of pictures, document repairs, compute repair costs, and then explain the damage costs to the tenants and owners.
So how is getting a house back in great condition facilitated? The bottom line: You get what you ask for! Ask the tenants (in specific terms) what you want them to do so you can give them their full security deposit back. Examples include:
1. Steam clean the carpets after vacating and leave the receipt as proof
2. Put clean air filters in all the vents
3. Clean out all the appliances, drawers, and cabinets
4. Don’t leave any personal items in the house
5. Put new batteries in the CO and smoke detectors
6. Leave all copies of the keys, garage door openers, HOA passes, etc.
7. Fill in wall holes and touch-up paint where appropriate
8. Make sure the landscaping has been trimmed and the grass cut
If expectations are set, then (at least some of) the tenants will follow them. And this will save some of the “I can’t believe how the tenant left the house!” laments. And also cushion the tenant protests if some of their security deposit is held back.
We can’t expect the tenants to leave a home in “good condition”, when we don’t define what “good condition” means to us. It’s a subjective term.
When tenants ask the #1 Question, they are listening very hard to your response. Give them the #1 Answer. Take this opportunity to detail how you want the property left (and providing a check-off sheet in writing is even better!) while they are focused. Then add, “… so depending on how the property is left and how many repair quotes we need, it could take up to 30 days. If it is left in great shape, you could get it in a few days!”
The #1 Question is good; it shows the tenants care. Make sure you volley back the #1 Answer while you have their full attention!
Brett Furniss is the President & Owner of BDF Realty (Charlotte Residential Property Management), the trusted real estate advisor for Charlotte landlords. BDF Realty utilizes their innovative Pod System for exceptional customer service in residential property management, home repairs, and home sales (including Rent-To-Sell) for single-family homes, condos, and town homes in the Charlotte-Metro Area. Contact Us Today!
Learn MorePutting Your Vacant Rental Home on the Market? 3 Steps To Be Prepared
The news has been all positive for home sellers. And some of you have been ready to sell some of your rental homes for the last 5 years!
The thought equation about selling your rental home looks like this:
Desire to Sell + Rapidly Improving Market + Now Vacant Rental Home = Time To Go To Market?
That is the big question. If the answer is “I think so!”, here are the next steps.
Talk to your property manager and have them run some comparables on your property. If it is determined that you have the room (difference between your rental home’s value and loan balance) to walk away from a sale with a profit (or an acceptable loss), you may decide you want to make a go at it.
If this is your situation, how do you prepare? Here are 3 easy steps:
1. Make sure you have the needed liquidity (cash) – Part 1: You’ll need to fix up your home to market standards. This may include a new paint job, new carpet, professional cleaning, and any other needed repairs.
2. Liquidity- Part 2: You should have a minimum of 4 to 6+ months of mortgage, HOA dues, lawn care, and utility payments at your disposal so everyone still gets paid during this time of vacancy. Unfortunately, you won’t have a tenant making the payments for you while it’s vacant on the market.
3. Decide what your boundaries are:
A. What is the lowest price you are willing to sell for (your property manager can help you factor in what your selling costs are)?
B. How long are you willing to wait to sell it before going back to the rental market?
Once these 3 criteria are considered and you are comfortable with them, it is time to go to market and trust the marketing prowess of your property manager. Then a new equation emerges:
Fixed-up home + Competitive Price + Funds Necessary to Execute the Sales Strategy = Sales Success!
Selling a rental home is a process that takes time and money. Successful execution depends on having the necessary resources and patience to see it through. Good luck!
Brett Furniss is President & Owner of BDF Realty (Charlotte Residential Property Management), the trusted real estate advisor for Charlotte landlords, managing single-family homes, Uptown condos, and town homes in the Charlotte-Metro Area. BDF Realty’s services include property management, home fix-ups, and home sales, including Rent-To-Sell (“When You Need a New Solution to Sell Your Home”). His newest book is A Real Estate Agent’s Complete Guide to Representing Rent-To-Own (Lease Option) Tenants (Delight Clients, Fill Vacant Homes, and Earn $2,250* Upfront! (*Minimum!) which is available on-line now.
Learn MoreSelling Your Rental Home With 24’s Villain, Habib Marwan
I was watching an old episode of 24 last night (Season 4 for fellow aficionados) and was intrigued by the moves of Habib Marwan, the terrorist leader. In order to distract Jack Bauer and the Counter Terrorist Unit (CTU), he proposes to trade captured CTU agent, Jack Bauer, for the teenage son (Behrooz) of known terrorists, Dina and Navi Araz.
Marwan actually has no use for Bayroos, but CTU doesn’t know that. The trade’s main purpose is to distract and slow down CTU from figuring out the next stage of his nefarious plan (stealing a stealth bomber and blowing up of Air Force One with President Keeler). He wants them to waste their time and resources going after the wrong lead trail with the Behrooz-Bauer exchange. The purposeful misdirection almost works…
I see this misdirection, though unintended, in home sales sometimes. As a home seller, you don’t want to distract and slow down potential buyers for your rental home! Like Marwan, you must decide who your real target is and focus. Marwan never wavered on his priority on taking down Air Force One. He used misdirection to achieve his main goal.
However, don’t use misdirection when selling your rental home! To avoid this, the decision must be made on whether to target owner occupants or investors; going after both (especially when the facts on your home won’t support a good selling proposition to one of the parties) is a waste of time and resources. CTU didn’t have time to track leads to find Marwan AND conduct the exchange for Jack Bauer. This misaligned strategy cost President Keeler his life and was a major intelligence failure.
How do you know whether you want to target an investor or an owner occupant as a buyer for your rental home? The correct strategy to utilize hinges on the answer.
Here are a few questions to ask to determine the appropriate strategy to use:
1. What is the ratio of the monthly rent versus the asking price? In Charlotte, investors ask for anywhere from .008 and up. To get this number, divide the rent by the home price. Ex: On a home for sale for $100K and a rent of $995/month, the ratio is .00995. A ratio near .01 is excellent. A ration closer to .005 – .006 will make it tough to sell to a cash-flow investor. For homes, subtract the monthly HOA dues (or annual dues pro-rated per month) from the monthly rental amount; this usually significantly lowers the ratio and is why many investors shy away from townhomes and condos.
2. What type of discount can be offered on the home? If it needs to sell for full retail, the owner occupant buyer is the way to go. If there is room to discount the home off of retail price, it may be a good candidate for an investor.
3. How much money can you afford to put towards fixing the home up? If it is a lot, then you have the option of fixing up the home nicely and asking for full retail price. If the funds are not available, investors are flexible on repairs if the deal on the home is enticing in terms of cash flow ratio (#1) and discounted off of retail price (#2).
4. Is there a tenant currently in the home? If so, this is a good candidate to sell to an investor and save the holding costs of vacancy. It costs nothing to have a home on the market while a tenant is in it, though there are some logistical issues for showings.
So, the ideal selling conditions per buyer type…
Investor: good cash flow ratio, home discounted, limited repairs done, tenant in property
Owner-occupant: poor cash flow ratio, full retail price, fix-up completed, empty house
Once it is determined who the ideal buyer is for your rental home, the marketing should flow from this decision. So…
Investors: offering your home at local investment clubs, ad verbiage including “signed lease and expenses log provided” in the listing as well as other pertinent investment factoids, posting on real estate investment websites, informing property managers and Realtors who know investors looking to acquire rentals that your home is available and a good deal
Owner-occupants: MLS and other marketing a typical Realtor would provide
Having an aligned strategy to your target market will save money and in Marwan’s case, take American lives! Fortunately for US citizens, Jack Bauer is good at focusing on his target (Marwan) as well…
Brett Furniss is President & Owner of BDF Realty (Charlotte Residential Property Management), the trusted real estate advisor for Charlotte landlords, managing single-family homes, Uptown condos, and town homes in the Charlotte-Metro Area. BDF Realty’s services include property management, home fix-ups, and home sales, including Rent-To-Sell (“When You Need a New Solution to Sell Your Home”). His newest book is A Real Estate Agent’s Complete Guide to Representing Rent-To-Own (Lease Option) Tenants (Delight Clients, Fill Vacant Homes, and Earn $2,250* Upfront! (*Minimum!) which is available on-line now.
Learn MoreCharlotte Property Management Monthly: Don’t Return Your Tenant’s Security Deposit Just Yet
As a Charlotte property manager, I am a big proponent of returning as much of the tenant’s security deposit to them as possible. If the tenant took time to care for the property, did what they were supposed to do during their lease period, and paid all of their rent, they certainly deserve it back! There is a reason property managers are required to put the security deposit into an escrow account; it is a reminder that the security deposit is not the landlord’s money, it belongs to the tenants.
However, that being said, I’m also a proponent of the “slow return.” By NC law, the security deposit does not need to be returned to the tenant for 30 days. And also according to the law, if the landlord is still figuring out repair costs and won’t make the 30-day deadline, they just need to notify the tenant that the payment will be delayed in writing and let them know the approximate cost of the repairs at that point in time.
Why would landlords delay the tenant’s security deposit return? The most popular question asked (by far) when a tenant moves out is, “when can I expect the security deposit back?” If you want to be a “cool” landlord, shouldn’t you just give it back after the walk-through? You already know how much the repairs are going to cost (if there are any) and the tenant could use the money back. You certainly want to be good to the tenants who were good to you, right?
Well, yes, but not exactly. I recommend keeping the security deposit as long as possible. Once it is given back, you really need to consider the tenant gone and their account closed. You need to assume that you will never get any money from them again.
So? They moved out already, right?
Yes, but… Walk-throughs are an inexact science and sometimes things are missed. Think about home inspectors; they are professionals that take hours doing a walk-through to write a comprehensive damage report and they still miss issues with the home. I guarantee that landlords are not close to conducting several hour walk-throughs at the level of detail that they are (nor should they be). Things get missed and that’s life.
However, you can provide yourself some extra time so missed things can get caught before it’s too late and you have to pay for it! It may be one of the handymen working on your home that alerts you to new repair issues. It may be a Realtor or marketing person who wonders why something looks off. Or (usually) it’s the next tenant who moves in afterwards that lets you know what’s not up to par (and by the way, they want the issues fixed on your dime!).
Let tenants pay for damages they are responsible for. And, unfortunately, the delay in returning the security deposit to them is a good way to ensure this happens.
Brett Furniss is the President & Owner of BDF Realty (Charlotte Property Management) which works with Charlotte real estate investors and homeowners and Rent-To-Sell Realty (“When You Need a New Solution to Sell Your Home”) which specialize in rent-to-own (lease options) and rent-to-sell homes. His newest book, A Real Estate Agent’s Complete Guide to Representing Rent-To-Own (Lease Option) Tenants (Delight Clients, Fill Vacant Homes, and Earn $2,250* Upfront! (*Minimum!)
Learn MoreCharlotte Property Management Monthly: Investment Confessions of a Property Manager- 4 Takeaways
Many property managers first get into the property management business because they own investment properties and are already managing them. “Why not add a few more? The infrastructure is already in place!” This rationale brought me into this exciting world of property management.
Becoming proficient at investments is an ever-evolving process. It takes a lot of easy education (reading the investments guru rags) and hard education (making costly mistakes with leveraged property investments).
This current economy has really put investment decisions I’ve made in the past 8 years under the microscope. In a hot real estate market, investment decisions have a lot of leeway to succeed. The converse is also true in a bad economy and leads me to ask questions like: Did the properties I bought maintain value (relatively speaking) or did I misread the area? Do renters want to live in these homes when much more choice became available? Can I sell any of these investment homes in a flat or declining real estate market?
Tough questions. And, unfortunately, some tough answers.
When I look at my investment decisions, I’ve come away with these 4 takeaways:
1. Cash (flow) is always king. Properties always cost more in terms of vacancy, repairs, and fix up than expected. I remember an investment guru telling me, “If you need to pull out a calculator when analyzing a real estate deal, the deal isn’t good enough to buy.” Amen to that. When declining rents hit, I was hit hard as well.
One effective tool I’ve used is to liquidate some 15 and 30-year mortgages into interest-only. This has dramatically helped cash flow on my property portfolio. When the economy improves, interest rates will rise and I may need to pay the piper. But then I can look at refinancing or selling the investment homes in a rising real estate market, as opposed to selling in a buyer’s market.
2. Buying cheap isn’t always good. For a while, I loved telling the story about buying a home on my credit card. Not anymore. The problem is the home isn’t in a great area (making it tough to rent or sell) and has needed significant fix-up funds through the years. Sometimes there is a reason why homes can be bought on the cheap.
I like to defend this decision by saying, “At the time I bought it, it was a great deal in a transitional area on the rise.” I must have missed the newsflash at the time; in an overheated real estate market, almost every area is considered “on the rise”. This reminds me of two sports quotes that seem apropos:
a. “Having ‘potential’ means that you haven’t accomplished anything yet.” I never read any articles on Michael Jordan’s potential, but rather about his performance.
b. “Yeah, he has great talent. But there are a lot of talented people in prison.”
3. I like a well-rounded real estate investment strategy; it does the body good. We get many calls from prospective clients looking for options on what to do with their properties. I’m with you! Options are good! Good options are even better!
My idea of a well-rounded real estate portfolio consists of this:
A. Nice, expensive homes that will rise when the market comes back. Cash flow won’t be great, but will generate a nice chunk of cash when the market goes up. Then they need to be sold!
B. Cash flow properties that generate hundreds of dollars of positive cash flow a month. These will subsidize other properties that aren’t cash flowing. They probably won’t see any great amount of equity build-up (even in a rising market), but they will keep you solvent and smiling!
C. Long-term holds will be nice investment pieces for retirement. They are solid homes in solid neighborhoods that are really a mixture of the A & B properties above. They will give average cash flow and equity build-up, but should be easy to rent to good tenants for a long time.
4. The most important takeaway (by far) is to buy investment homes right (aka at a big of a discount as possible). This can cover up a whole lot of other mistakes. As another investment guru told me, “You make your money when you buy. Period.”
Best of luck with your real estate investing!
Brett Furniss is the President & Owner of BDF Realty (“Charlotte’s Most Innovative Property Management & Investment Company”), and Rent-To-Sell Realty (“When You Need a New Solution to Sell Your Home”) which specialize in rent-to-own (lease options) and rent-to-sell homes. His newest book, A Real Estate Agent’s Complete Guide to Representing Rent-To-Own (Lease Option) Tenants (Delight Clients, Fill Vacant Homes, and Earn $2,250* Upfront! (*Minimum!)
Learn MoreCharlotte Property Management Monthly: Rental Home E-Harmony: What Tenant Is Perfect For Your Rental?
Dating web sites, like E-Harmony and Match.com, have grown in popularity and are apparently very effective; one in five people getting married met on-line, their advertising claims. That’s pretty good!
It can be even better for real estate. Many polls conclude that 90%+ of home searches begin on-line! Real estate web sites have the potential to be much better matchmakers!
But the real test of effectiveness is how many leases are consummated (for lack of a better word) from this on-line home matchmaking. And whether the landlords and tenants are happy with the union after move-in. Much like the 4 out of 5 people who don’t get married from the dating sites, sometimes it doesn’t work out between the landlords and tenants. Why not?
Maybe this matchmaking could be much more effective if there was a lot more honesty going on from both sides of the deal?
For example, on-line ads for homes tend to look like this regardless of what the home actually looks like:
Immaculate & cozy, this 3 BR / 2 BA stunner can make even the most choosy renter’s heart melt. Beautiful home with too many upgrades to count. Voted safest and best run neighborhood in Elmwood for 2 of the last 3 years (as reported by the Elmwood HOA Newsletter)! Priced attractively at $1,200/month and is sure to go fast!
And if the renter had an ad? It would read something like this:
Ideal tenants seek quiet abode for a loving family. Our 8 dogs are trained in Vienna (on Vienna Drive in Lincroft, NJ, it turns out…) and have never soiled a single fiber of carpet. Our rent is always paid on time and the only time the police come to our home is when we make them hot chocolate after they are done caroling in our neighborhood. We love our landlords and they love us!
But what is the truth? No tenants or landlords are filling out a 300-question survey where algorithms are going to match the tenant and house together. Each of them is going to claim that what they offer is top of the line, no matter what the real truth is. The problem for the landlord is that the tenant can see the home and make a determination if the rental ad is true, while the landlord must run an application and make a partially subjective decision on information gathered during the application process.
So how can landlords get the type of tenant they want? It really goes beyond the rental application. Much like dating is about being the mate that you want to attract, rental homes are the same way. What???
Generally-speaking, it’s a simple truth and goes like this:
If the rental house is in a safe area, priced economically, and immaculate, the chances rise exponentially that tenant it attracts will not be a criminal, be economical (buys things valued properly), and value cleanliness.
On the other hand, if the house is in a crime-ridden area, overpriced, and dirty, the tenant it attracts will more likely be involved in more shady dealings, spend recklessly (re: which may lead them into situations where they struggle to pay rent), and not care about the cleanliness of the home.
So, in practical terms, should the spots in the carpet be cleaned out prior to going to market? Yes, if the landlord wants a tenant who rents the home to care about spots on the carpet. What about cleaning the appliances? Only if the landlord cares about attracting tenants who care about clean appliances. Should the highest rent possible be asked for? Only if the landlord wants a tenant who doesn’t conduct research on their biggest expenditures which may signal their overall financial shakiness.
Much like humans, homes attract suitable mates. Good-looking people marry other good-looking people. Clean people rent clean houses. Financially responsible people don’t lock into overpriced rental homes.
What type of renter will your rental home naturally attract? Or more importantly, turn off?
Brett Furniss is the President & Owner of BDF Realty (“Charlotte’s Most Innovative Property Management & Investment Company”), and Rent-To-Sell Realty (“When You Need a New Solution to Sell Your Home”) which specialize in rent-to-own (lease options) and rent-to-sell homes. His newest book, A Real Estate Agent’s Complete Guide to Representing Rent-To-Own (Lease Option) Tenants (Delight Clients, Fill Vacant Homes, and Earn $2,250* Upfront! (*Minimum!)
Learn MoreCharlotte Property Management Monthly: Should I Even Bother to Try to Sell My House in this Market?
This is a question that I was posed on a call last week. For property managers, this is a no-brainer, right? It’s like any buying question to a salesperson in any industry:
Question from prospective client:
Do I need a haircut?
Barber:
Absolutely.
Question from prospective client:
Do I need insurance coverage for (fill in the blank)?
Answer from insurance agent:
Absolutely. If your family’s (fill in the blank) is important, it would potentially be devastating to live without it.
Question from potential client:
Can my house sell in this market? It didn’t with the past 2 real estate agents I used.
Answer from real estate agent (straight faced without blinking):
Absolutely! My team has a 10-point marketing plan that can sell any house in any market*!
* With a nominal 50% price reduction
So back to the original question:
Should someone even bother to try to sell their house in this market?
My answer:
It depends.
Depends on what?
You should try to sell your home if you:
1. Are living in the house and don’t have to move
2. Have a clean tenant who is amenable to showings
3. Have a unique house (be honest!) that is desirable in any market
4. Are able to afford to price the house competitively (aka on the low end)
5. Are willing to gamble and eat the rent every month and wait for a buyer who might or might not come
My answer to not bother putting the house on the market for sale is under the following conditions:
1. There are several foreclosures and short sales active in your home’s subdivision
2. You can’t afford to or don’t want to drastically discount your home price
3. The home is vacant and #3, #4, and/or #5 above don’t apply to you
4. Neighbors’ homes that are priced around the level you want to sell yours for are sitting
The simple truth is that the buy & sell real estate market is continuing on a sharp downtrend with no end in sight, while the rental market is on a sharp uptrend. Everyone still needs a place to live, but the banks are not willing to lend to less than perfect borrowers. This leads to a surplus of rental and rent-to-own tenants, and a dearth of buyers. So the question is if it is better to go fishing at the small pond stocked with thousands of fish or the big pond with 25?
Whether it still makes sense to list your home for sale really depends on your answers to the questions above. Truthfully, for most people, the best financial option is to stay put in their home. But going straight to the rental or rent-to-sell market is best for people who are:
1. In a time crunch
2. Need to move
3. Can’t or don’t want to afford 2 mortgage payments
Often, it just doesn’t make sense to put the home on the market for sale. It’s an exercise in futility and costs a good deal of money. It’s like asking out the head cheerleader to the prom when you know you are going to wind up going with Suzy next door anyway. You might as well cut to the chase and save yourself the time, expense, and effort.
That being said, one size never fits all. Determine what criteria above fit your situation and act accordingly!
Brett Furniss is the President & Owner of BDF Realty (“Charlotte’s Most Innovative Property Management & Investment Company”), and Rent-To-Sell Realty (“When You Need a New Solution to Sell Your Home”) which specialize in rent-to-own (lease options) and rent-to-sell homes. His newest book, A Real Estate Agent’s Complete Guide to Representing Rent-To-Own (Lease Option) Tenants (Delight Clients, Fill Vacant Homes, and Earn $2,250* Upfront! (*Minimum!)
Learn MoreCharlotte Property Management Monthly: Multiple Rental Offer Situations: Is Engagement The Same As Marriage?
So you’re walking down the street the day after successfully proposing marriage to your girlfriend, who now (you’ve been told) is to be referred as your “fiancée”. You’re happy and are convinced she was meant to be “The One”. But, wait; is that the beautiful Sasha Blue across the street? The girl of your dreams who always had those model boyfriends that put you permanently into the “friend” category? Is she looking at you? I think she is!
As you get closer, Miss Blue excitedly runs up to you. “Max, is that you? I was hoping to run into you! I finally got rid of that no-good Antonio! Wow… Is this the first time we are both single at the same time? How exciting! I’d love to catch up!”
As your heart races, your memory of getting down on one knee the night before is fading fast. Is it too late to run a reverse and go after Miss Blue? Engagement isn’t legally binding, is it? It’s a very interesting conundrum!
That is the same question that faces property management companies when multiple tenants apply for the same property at different times. At what engagement point prior to move-in is a tenant “locked” in and the property manager must forsake all other suitors?
Let’s look at a potential scenario: Tenant A applies for a property and is approved. They have not put a deposit down on the property yet. Tenant B sees the property the next day and loves it. They are a stronger applicant and are willing to pay more money per month. However, when talking with Tenant B, Tenant A puts down the deposit. Company policy is that whoever puts down the deposit first with an approved application gets the house. So, is Tenant B out of luck?
In most scenarios, yes. But there is a caveat. The property manager works for the owner. It is their job to get the best applicant that fits the home owner’s (aka their client’s) goals. Should the overall mandate to pursue what’s best for the owner trump company policy?
The easy answer is “of course!” The practical answer is yes and no- the solid, business school “it depends” response. On one hand, I don’t think it is reasonable to take a deposit from an approved tenant, keep the house on the market at a higher rate, and then renege on the agreement if another tenant appears that is willing to pay more. That could leave an applicant who dealt with the property management in good faith potentially homeless and dealing with the hassle of changing addresses, utilities, moving vans, and losing their piece of mind. This generates hate mail (rightfully so).
But, on the other hand, at what point is it reasonable to accept competing offers?
I believe that up until the tenant is told definitively that the home is theirs is a reasonable time to protect the owner’s interests. That may mean that if multiple applications come in (and even after deposits are put down), there is still time to review the applicants and decide which one is best for the owner. If the applicants are similar, then the first one who applied and put down a deposit should be given first dibs.
However, what about if the following applicant situations present themselves?
1. An applicant with a 600 credit score with average landlord history is approved and puts down a deposit before a 700 credit score applicant with great landlord history
2. 2 applicants are equal but one is willing to pay a higher monthly rent
3. 2 applicants are equal but one is willing to pay the year of rent upfront
4. One applicant is willing to move-in 3 weeks prior to the other
In these situations (if prior to giving “official” notice that the house is locked in for a certain tenant), then it is really imperative to choose the tenant that offers the best deal for the owner.
However, once official notice is given, I don’t believe it is ethical to offer the home to anyone else, regardless of the deal offered. The only way to supersede this is if the one tenant “buys out” the other in a separate negotiation. Money can make things happen!
So, if you asked to marry your fiancée, told her she was definitely “The One”, and gave her a ring, Miss Blue should be off limits. It may not be legally binding, but it’s the right thing to do.
Learn MoreCharlotte Property Management Weekly: The “Additional Security Deposit” Letter Exchange
Dear Property Manager,
I am very interested in the rental house you have listed! I think it will be perfect for our family. However, when you asked me for an additional month of security deposit, it made me concerned. Money doesn’t grow on trees these days and I thought the rental ad said you only needed one month down. We also have to come up with the first month’s rent and pet fees, so you’re talking about a pretty big sum already. I’ll be honest, I just don’t have it.
I explained our situation to you. The economy had turned against us, but we’re past it! My wife is employed again and getting you the rent will be no problem. Haven’t you ever had anything happen to you before? Have a heart! We’d take great care of the home, but just need the security deposit reduced. My business is booming so things will be fine! Don’t worry! You’ll get your money!
So what do you say? Can you help me out?
Sincerely,
Mr. Tenant
P.S. My wife thought you looked exquisite in your emerald blazer! It’s a bold move to wear it in 97 degree heat, if you ask me, but it’s better to look good than feel good, right?
Mr. Tenant,
Thank your wife for the kind words about my blazer. Typically they run the air conditioning at 40 below (so I try to stay prepared), but it didn’t work well when we moved outside. Emerald has sort of grown on me as I’ve gotten older. I think it complements my eyes, but opinions sometimes vary. You know, you make a call on the outfit every morning and sometimes you hit it out of the park and sometimes you whiff. Truth be told, I’d settle for hitting singles in the clothing department!
As for the request for additional security deposit monies, I understand your concern. Let me explain our rationale.
I understand you hit a rough spot a year ago; that happens. It’s obviously not just you; we see applications like this everyday. We also rent to a lot of people who have hit rough spots before! It’s not a deal-killer.
But there are other mitigating factors. Let’s look at your credit application and income. Your scores are obviously not good, but I’m not overly worried about that. There looks to be some recent 30-day late payments on power bills and cable. Your current landlord said that you had a few late payments as well during their lease (at an amount less than you would be paying now). You gave us your business bank statements to show your income, but it’s not clear how much of that actually makes it to you. This information collectively gives me pause about your financial condition.
My job as a property manager is to mitigate risk for our client, the owner of the home you want to rent. I personally think you would be a great tenant; anyone who compliments my wardrobe is good in my book! But if something happened to you that turned into a decent size expense, I can’t say with much certainty (with the information we have) that your lease wouldn’t be at risk. If an extra thousand dollar deposit is a deal-killer from your end, what would happen if your car stopped running next week? You obviously would need to fix that first to get to work. The owner of the home would be left waiting for their payment. And we wouldn’t be doing our job well.
If you have something that addresses these concerns, please send this information over so we can consider it! We make money by filling properties, so we want to approve you! We just have to protect our clients first.
I hope this letter clears the air. Thank you for your interest in our home and I hope we can work together in the future.
Sincerely,
Your Property Manager
P.S. On your suggestion, I’m wearing a short-sleeved cotton blend shirt today, no jacket. It feels good- thanks for the suggestion!
Learn More